Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Modest Menswear Thobes

Sujud Collection CRO Audit

A CRO teardown of Sujud Collection's homepage, shop page and product page, showing why a new quarter-zip thobe needs explaining before visitors will buy, plus a full redesign concept.

13
Issues found
17
Fixes proposed
22
Minutes of tape
2.6
Overall / 10
22 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 22-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

Sujud Collection starts from a strong place. The product is a good idea: a quarter-zip thobe that the store presents as the first of its kind, made for a specific audience with a real need. The range is focused, with three variants rather than a sprawling catalogue, and nothing in the audit suggested the product itself is the weak point. The opportunity is in how the site presents it.

The core problem is that the site does not help visitors feel confident enough to buy. A 15% off pop-up appears the moment they land, and the hero shows the product with a line about it being first of its kind and an order button. It does not say what the product is, who it is for, or why a visitor should trust a new brand. After three pictures, the homepage ends.

The same pattern repeats deeper in. The shop page is a grid of three products with no guidance on which to choose or why. The product page has a name, a price and size options, and nothing else. For a new kind of garment, where fit and sizing are the main worry, that leaves the visitor to work everything out alone, and confused visitors hesitate and leave.

The direction is to treat the website as the salesman for the business, not a catalogue. The homepage explains the brand and its values, the shop page helps visitors find their fit and choose a variant, and the product page answers sizing, fabric and returns questions next to the buy button. A new product needs explaining before it can be sold.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The store shows a new kind of thobe but never explains it. The homepage, shop page and product page say what is for sale and stop there, so visitors leave without knowing what it is, who it suits or why to buy.

Main opportunity

Sujud Collection could become a store that acts like a salesman: a homepage that explains the brand, a shop page with a fit finder that helps visitors choose, and a product page that answers every sizing and quality doubt.

Estimated impact

Visitors would understand the product within seconds, find the right variant and size without guessing, and reach the buy button with their doubts answered, so more of the existing traffic would buy.

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

2.6 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
5 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 4/10
UX 3/10
Trust 2/10
Product Page 2/10
Conversion 2/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

13 issues found, 17 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Discount Pop-Up Appears The Moment Visitors Land

A 15% off pop-up opens as soon as the site loads, before the visitor has seen the product. It interrupts the first impression and gives away margin to people who have not shown any intent yet.

Hero Does Not Say What The Product Is

The hero shows the quarter-zip thobe with a line saying it is the first of its kind and an order button. A first-time visitor is not told what makes it different or what problem it solves.

Homepage Never Says Who The Thobe Is For

Nothing on the homepage names the audience or the occasions the thobe is made for, so visitors cannot quickly tell whether the product is meant for them.

No Reason To Trust A New Brand

The store reads as a new business, yet the homepage offers nothing that builds trust: no brand story, no reviews, no people wearing the product, and no explanation of how it is made.

Homepage Ends After Three Pictures

Below the hero there are three images and then the page stops. There is no buying path leading visitors from interest to the product they should choose.

Benefits Of The Product Are Not Explained

The site does not set out why someone should wear this thobe over what they already own. The fabric, the design choices and the practical benefits are left unsaid.

Shop Page Works As A Catalogue, Not A Guide

The shop page shows a grid of three products with no copy around them. It tells visitors what is available but does nothing to help them decide.

No Help Choosing Between The Three Variants

Visitors are not told how the Signature, Defined and Limited Edition versions differ, so they have to guess which one suits them or give up choosing.

Product Page Shows Only Name, Price And Size

The product page has the product name, the price and a size selector, and that is the whole page. There is no description, no detail and nothing that makes the case for buying.

Sizing Is Left For The Visitor To Work Out

Thobes are sized by length, which is unfamiliar to people used to T-shirt sizes. The site gives no fit guidance, so the main worry a buyer has goes unanswered.

No Reassurance Near The Buy Button

Delivery terms, exchanges for the wrong size and care information are not shown beside the add to cart button, which is exactly where hesitation happens.

No Reviews Or Photos Of Real Wearers

There are no reviews and no photography of real people wearing the thobe, so visitors cannot see how it looks and fits on someone like them.

Brand Values And Price Are Not Explained

The site does not explain the values behind the brand or why the thobe costs what it does compared with a typical import, so the price stands without context.

Recommendations

Remove The Discount Pop-Up On Arrival

Take the 15% off pop-up off the landing experience. If an offer is needed up front, lead with free shipping instead, which costs less and does not train visitors to wait for a code.

Use The Discount To Recover Abandoned Visitors

Send the 15% offer through retargeting to people who visited or started checkout without finishing, so the discount rewards intent instead of being given to everyone.

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

Make the hero say what the quarter-zip thobe is, who it is for and why to trust the brand, all readable within the first three seconds of landing.

Build A Full Buying Path On The Homepage

Extend the homepage beyond three pictures into a sequence that explains the product, its benefits, the fabric, the brand and the reasons to buy, ending in a clear route to the shop.

Add A Shop By Occasion Section

Help visitors find the right thobe by showing which variant suits which occasion, so they can start from their own situation instead of a product grid.

Compare The Three Variants Side By Side

Add a comparison of Signature, Defined and Limited Edition that explains what differs between them, so choosing a version becomes a quick decision.

Explain Sizing By Length In T-Shirt Terms

Show how thobe sizes by length relate to the T-shirt sizes visitors already know, so the unfamiliar sizing system stops being a reason to hesitate.

Show Model Heights Next To The Size Worn

Photograph men of different heights in the thobe and label each with his height and the size he is wearing, so visitors can match themselves to a real example.

Build A Find My Fit Quiz

Ask visitors their height, their usual T-shirt size and how they like a garment to fit, then recommend the product and size, so they never have to work it out alone.

Turn The Shop Page Into A Guided Selection

Introduce the three products with copy explaining which one is for whom, add a fit strip on how sizing works, and place reviews on the page.

Place Reassurances Beside Add To Cart

Put free delivery, size exchanges, the charity contribution and care instructions directly next to the buy button, where the purchase decision is made.

Write A Full Product Description

Describe the fabric, the quality, the design choices and why this style works, so the product page makes the case for the thobe instead of only listing it.

Add Reviews And Real Customer Photography

Add a reviews and trust section with photos of real people wearing the thobe. If reviews are not available yet, plan a way to gather them early in launch.

Tell The Brand Story And Values

Add a values section covering the charity giving behind each sale and what the brand stands for, so visitors buy into the business and not only the garment.

Explain The Price Against Typical Imports

Show what separates this thobe from a typical import in fabric and construction, so the price reads as justified rather than simply stated.

Offer A Bundle Reward For Buying Two

Replace the arrival discount with a reward for buying two together, shown as a complete the pair section at the end of the product page.

Add FAQs To The Homepage And Product Page

Answer the common questions about fit, fabric, delivery and exchanges on the pages where they come up, so visitors do not leave to find answers.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

Redesign frames not yet published
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • The biggest opportunity for Sujud Collection is not more traffic but helping the traffic it already has feel confident enough to buy.
  • A discount shown the moment someone lands gives away margin to a visitor who has not earned it yet.
  • A homepage has three seconds to say what the product is, who it is for and why the visitor should trust the brand.
  • A shop page of three products with no guidance behaves like a catalogue, not a salesman.
  • When the product is new, the site has to explain it before it can sell it.
  • For a thobe sized by length, fit is the main worry, and a fit finder removes it before it becomes hesitation.
  • The homepage should explain the brand, the shop page should help visitors choose, and the product page should help them decide.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

Sujud Collection sells a quarter-zip thobe that the store presents as the first of its kind. The range has three variants: Signature, Defined and Limited Edition. The audit found the product itself to be a strong idea for a specific audience.

The site does not help visitors feel confident enough to buy. It shows the product but never explains what it is, who it is for or why to trust a new brand. That pattern runs from the homepage through to the product page.

It appears the moment a visitor lands, before they have seen the product or shown any intent. The audit recommends removing it, leading with free shipping if an offer is needed, and saving the discount for retargeting or a buy two reward.

Three questions within the first three seconds: what the product is, who it is for, and why the visitor should buy it or trust the business. The current hero only says the thobe is first of its kind and offers an order button.

It shows a grid of three products with no guidance. Visitors are not told how the variants differ or which one suits them, so the page works as a catalogue instead of helping them choose.

Almost everything beyond the name, price and size selector. There is no description, no fabric detail, no fit guidance, no reviews and no reassurance about delivery or exchanges near the buy button.

Thobes are sized by length, which is unfamiliar to people used to T-shirt sizes. Fit is the main concern for a buyer, and the current site leaves them to work it out alone, which is where hesitation starts.

It asks the visitor their height, their usual T-shirt size and how they like a garment to fit. Based on the answers it recommends the product and size to buy, so the visitor does not have to guess.

It rebuilds the homepage to explain the brand, adds shop by occasion, a variant comparison, sizing in T-shirt terms, real wearer photos, values and FAQs. The shop page gains a fit finder and guidance, and the product page gains reassurances, detail and a complete the pair offer.

No. It is a strategic design concept put together by the Convertica design team to show what the store could look like once the problems in the audit are fixed. It is not final design and not a working site.

The audit acknowledges that a new brand may not have reviews at launch. It still recommends a reviews and trust section with real people wearing the product, and notes there are ways to gather that proof early.

The video runs about 22 minutes. It reviews the Sujud Collection homepage, shop page and product page, then walks through a full redesign concept covering the homepage, the Find My Fit feature, the collection page and the product page.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.