Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Printed Graphic Tees UK

Paul Martin Martin CRO Audit

A page by page teardown of a UK printed graphic tee store, covering the homepage, a collection page and a product page, plus a redesign concept built around guided buying paths.

13
Issues found
15
Fixes proposed
29
Minutes of tape
3.2
Overall / 10
29 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 29-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

The store has a real range of printed graphic tees with plenty of personality, from slogan designs such as Born to Be Wild and Brains Are Overrated to seasonal themes. The products are not the weak point. A visitor can see clothing worth considering, and a price point like £25 is easy to accept once trust is in place.

The core problem is the presentation layer. The homepage does not say what the business does, who it is for, or why it can be trusted. A visitor can tell it sells clothing from the name alone, and the navigation, the hero and the Shop Now prompts give no sense of direction, so hesitation starts in the first few seconds.

The same problem repeats further down. The collection page lists images, names and prices like a catalog, with only standard Shopify sorting. Two tees look identical without opening each page. On the product page, measurements, delivery, returns and reviews are missing, so the questions a buyer has go unanswered.

The direction is to act like a good shop assistant. Win trust at the top, offer clear paths by collection, moment, budget and gift, and use a fit finder to recommend the right tee. Then back every product with reviews, sizing and delivery answers. The idea to remember is that the visitor needs guiding, not just showing.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The site presents products like a catalog. It never says what the business is, never answers fit, delivery or returns questions, and shows no reviews, so first time visitors have no reason to trust it.

Main opportunity

The store could become a guided shop where the homepage explains the brand in seconds, navigation and a fit finder lead each visitor to the right tee, and reviews and bundles support a larger basket.

Estimated impact

A visitor who understands the brand, finds the right tee faster and sees proof and answers on the product page is far more likely to buy, and to add a second item. Existing traffic works harder.

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

3.2 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
5 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 4/10
UX 4/10
Trust 2/10
Product Page 3/10
Conversion 3/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

13 issues found, 15 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Hero Does Not Explain The Business

The first screen does not say what the store sells, who it is for, or why a stranger should trust it. Beyond the brand name, a visitor cannot tell what makes this clothing different.

Navigation Offers No Guided Buying Paths

Hovering over the navigation reveals nothing useful. There are no routes by collection, occasion, budget or gifting, so the menu misses its chance to help a visitor start exploring.

Shop By Collection Starts Mid Page

The collection section begins partway down the page and does not tell the visitor which collections or types of apparel exist. The space feels unfinished rather than directional.

Shop Now Appears Before Any Orientation

Visitors are asked to shop now before they know what the store offers. It is like greeting someone at a shop door with a hard sell before they have looked around.

Collection Page Behaves Like A Catalog

The page is a grid of images, names and prices. It lists what is available but does little to help a visitor discover, compare or choose between products.

Sorting Stops At Price And Availability

Only the standard Shopify theme sorting is offered, covering price and availability. There are no filters for design, colour, garment or size to narrow a long list.

Product Cards Look Identical At A Glance

Born to Be Wild and Brains Are Overrated share the same colour and price, and the cards say nothing more. A shopper must open five or six pages to compare, and may leave frustrated.

Product Pages Give No Size Measurements

The product page shows a name, price, colour and size, but no measurements. The first question in a buyer's mind is whether it will fit, and the page does not answer it.

Delivery And Returns Go Unmentioned

Nothing on the product page says when an order will arrive, what delivery costs or how returns work. These are the objections that stop a first time buyer at the Add to Cart button.

No Reviews Appear Anywhere On The Site

A new visitor spending £25 with an unfamiliar brand looks for other customers' experiences. With no reviews on any page, there is no proof that anyone has bought and been happy.

Nothing Sets The Brand Apart

The site does not explain why to buy from this store rather than from Etsy, Amazon or a cheaper seller. Fabric, print quality and UK production are not used to justify the price.

Nothing Encourages A Larger Basket

There are no bundles, pairing suggestions or free delivery thresholds. A customer buying one tee is never shown a jacket or a second item to go with it.

About And Charity Links Lead Nowhere

Clicking About or other links does not take the visitor anywhere useful, and the charity programme is not described on the site. A genuine trust asset is left unused.

Recommendations

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

State what the store sells, who it is for and why it can be trusted in the first screen. Add proof points such as printed in the UK, fabric weight and size exchange next to a clear call to action.

Add A Reassurance Bar To The Top Of Every Page

Place a slim bar above the header with free UK delivery above a set order value, designed and printed in the UK, and easy returns, so trust signals appear before the visitor scrolls.

Rebuild The Navigation Around Buying Paths

Organise the shop menu by collection, department, price band and moment. Let a visitor reach Christmas, Halloween, Gothic or Remembrance tees, or an under budget range, in one click.

Add A Gifting Route

Create a gifting section in the menu and on the homepage. Visitors who arrive without something in mind can be given ideas for loved ones and occasions they had not considered.

Add A Statement Finder Quiz

Ask a few questions such as size and style, then recommend one tee and two close alternatives. It acts like an assistant in a physical shop asking how it can help.

Move Shop By Collection Higher And Fill It

Show each collection with a clear image and name directly under the hero. A visitor should see the range of themes before being asked to buy anything.

Turn The Collection Page Into A Discovery Tool

Open each collection with a short description and dispatch information. Add garment toggles for tees and sweatshirts so visitors can narrow the range without leaving the page.

Add Filters And Sorting Beyond The Default

Offer filters for garment, design, colour, price and size, and sorting that reflects how people shop. Include the finder as a fallback for visitors who are unsure.

Make Product Cards Self Explanatory

Add badges such as bestseller or customer favourite, a short description, review stars, available sizes and price. Two similar tees should be comparable without opening either page.

Add Measurements And A Size Guide To Product Pages

Show a size guide beside the size selector and add a fit finder that recommends a size from the buyer's own details. Remove the doubt about whether the tee will fit.

Answer Delivery And Returns Beside The Button

Show an order by date for arrival, dispatch time, free size exchange, returns and secure checkout under Add to Cart. Repeat these answers in an FAQ lower on the page.

Show Storewide Reviews Where Product Reviews Are Missing

Where a tee has no reviews yet, display storewide reviews and customer photos with honest wording. Add a recent reviews section on the homepage and each collection page.

Explain Why To Buy Here Instead Of Elsewhere

Use short sections to explain the heavy cotton blend, the print quality, the cut and the UK production. Give the buyer reasons to pay for it over a cheaper marketplace tee.

Add Bundles And A Free Delivery Progress Bar

Offer build your own pairs and pre built bundles, plus a bar showing how much more to spend for free delivery. Suggest a jacket or second tee to complete the look.

Publish The About And Charity Pages

Create real pages for the founder, the artist and the charity programme, and link them from the homepage. Give shoppers a human reason to trust and remember the brand.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.

Homepage

The full page shown as two tall columns, from the first screen through the collections to the footer, so the whole journey reads at once.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Homepage, two tall columns

Three pages together

The homepage in the centre, the product page on the left with its buy column, and a collection page on the right with its header, filters and first cards.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Homepage centre, product left, collection right

The bag

A slide-over opens on top of the product page with five lines, so the shopper keeps their place and sees the delivery progress without leaving.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

The Statement Finder

Five screens on one board: who it is for, the moment, the fit, the size, and the recommended tee with the reasons it was picked.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Statement Finder, step by step

Product page

The full page as two tall columns, with the buy box whole on the left and the page running down to the footer on the right.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Product page, two tall columns

Product first screen

The header and the buy box together: sizes, the fit note, the add to bag button and the delivery and exchange lines, all in the first view.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Product page first screen: header and buy box

Collection page

The first screen with the collection banner, quick shortcuts, filters and the first row of tees with their badges.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

Mega menu

Each of the six panels open in nav order: Shop, Collections, Remembrance, Gifts, The Studio and Help, each with its own lists, featured tees or tiles.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Mega menu, every panel open

Search

The bar with a design name typed in the header, then the results page for that word with topic buttons and tees showing size range and price.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Search, the bar and the results

Phone screens

The home, collection and product screens side by side on mobile, built for the way most shoppers browse.

Paul Martin Martin concept redesign: Three phone screens: home, collection, product
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • A store can have good products and still lose sales if the homepage does not say what it sells, who it is for and why it can be trusted.
  • Navigation is the first sales tool; a menu that reveals no collections, moments or budgets wastes the most visible guidance on the site.
  • A collection page that only lists images, names and prices is a catalog, and shoppers will not compare similar tees by opening every page.
  • Product cards should carry badges, short descriptions, reviews, sizes and prices so a shopper can decide at a glance.
  • Fit, delivery and returns answers belong beside the Add to Cart button; without them a first time buyer hesitates.
  • With no reviews, a new visitor has no proof that anyone has bought and been happy, and storewide reviews can fill the gap.
  • Fixing conversion on the current traffic comes first; more ad spend only multiplies a leaking funnel.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

The audit finds that the biggest opportunity is converting the traffic already arriving, not buying more. Until the pages reassure and guide visitors, extra ad spend sends more people into the same hesitation. Fix the store first, then scale traffic.

The hero does not say what the business sells, who it is for or why it can be trusted. A visitor can only infer from the brand name that it sells clothing. The first few seconds should answer all three questions.

It behaves like a catalog, listing images, names and prices with only the standard Shopify sorting. Similar tees cannot be told apart without opening each page. Filters, badges and short summaries would make discovery much easier.

They show the problem clearly. Same colour, same price and nothing else to compare, so a shopper cannot tell which is right. A summary and badge on each card lets a buyer decide at a glance.

Measurements, delivery information, returns information and reviews are all absent. Those are the questions a buyer asks before paying. The page needs to justify the price and show that the purchase is safe.

Use storewide reviews and customer photos, and say plainly that they come from other products. A new visitor sees that real people have bought from the brand and were happy, which supports the decision.

It is a route that helps a visitor reach the right product without browsing everything. Examples are navigation by collection, moment or budget, a gifting section and a quiz that recommends a tee based on size and style.

It adds a free delivery progress bar, pairing suggestions on the product page and bundles on the homepage and collection page. The aim is for one customer to buy two or three items rather than one.

FAQs answer delivery, returns and payment questions at the point of decision. They also give search engines and AI assistants clear answers to draw from, which can help the store be found.

The concept shows what the three pages could look like. The store can leave things as they are, implement the ideas itself, or have the studio build them. The audit lays out these options at the end.

The recommended next step is a short call to discuss scope, questions and concerns. If a call is not convenient, the owner can send questions by email and receive written answers.

The audit reviews the homepage, a collection page and a product page of the store at mart-inc.co.uk, then walks through a redesign concept for each. The recording runs for 29 minutes.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.