Storefronts we designed and built, across supplements, fragrance, health, wellness and skincare.
All 35 projectsFour engagements, measured before and after. What changed, why it changed, and by how much.
All case studiesDiagnosis, design and development from one studio — so the recommendation and the build never disagree.
All five services160 real Shopify stores torn down page by page, scored, and shown beside the version we would build. Free to watch.
Browse all teardownsSix conversion-first themes, each built for one industry’s buying journey. Zero required apps, $300, one licence.
Compare all sixA CRO teardown of Above The Rest, a Shopify gift store selling engraved mugs, journals and boxed gifts, covering the homepage, the mugs collection and the product page, followed by a proposed redesign of all three.
Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.
Above The Rest sells engraved mugs, journals and boxed gifts, and the products themselves hold up. Our CRO strategist singled out the mug range as genuinely attractive, the standard and luxury box options as a sensible choice, and the note that most products are assembled and shipped from the USA as a real guarantee. The product page already shows secure checkout, stock counts and a delivery estimate.
The core problem is that nothing tells a new visitor where they are or why to trust the site. The hero shows a big logo, a stock photo of an anxious man and the line shop new trending gifts every day. It never says what the brand does, who the gifts are for, or whether anyone else has bought here. Reviews are missing from every page, and the reviews button opens nothing.
That gap repeats further down. Under the hero every bestseller is on sale, so the discount means nothing, and add to cart only appears on hover. The mugs collection marks every item as a bestseller and every item as reduced, with no filters, no sizes and no way to compare. The product page has the right pieces, urgency, delivery timing, secure checkout, but they sit scattered and the sticky header eats the screen.
The redesign turns the homepage into a salesperson. The hero says what the store does and who it is for, backed by reviews and a shipping and guarantee bar. A gift finder asks who it is for, the occasion, the budget and the date, then recommends products. Collection cards explain themselves and the product page adds gift wrap and a bundle. The one idea to keep: win trust first, then show a path.
The site never tells a new visitor what the store does, who the gifts are for, or whether anyone has bought here before. There are no reviews on any page, and the hero shows a logo and a stock photo instead of answering those questions.
The products are already good and the gifting angle is clear once you dig. With a hero that states the offer, a review strip, a gift finder and shop by recipient, occasion and gift type paths, the same traffic could be guided from landing to checkout.
The recording does not state traffic or revenue. It argues that visitors already arriving would hesitate less, find a gift faster, and add wrap, cards and paired items, lifting orders and average orde
Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.
14 issues found, 18 fixes proposed.
A visitor lands on a large logo, a stock photo of an anxious man and the line shop new trending gifts every day. Nothing states what the brand sells, who it is for, or why it can be trusted.
The bar holding the search field, cart and logo stays fixed as you scroll and takes up a large share of the viewport on every page, so nothing below can be seen in full without extra scrolling.
The first section under the hero shows bestsellers with every single item discounted. When everything is on sale, no discount reads as a reason to choose one product over another.
Homepage and collection cards show a percentage off, a name and a price. The quick buy button only appears on mouse hover, so a visitor is shown products with no visible way to act on them.
A section titled most popular gifts lists products without saying who they suit or which occasion they fit. A gift shopper cannot tell whether any of them is right for the person they have in mind.
The delivery, shipping and secure checkout reassurances exist, but they are placed at the very foot of the page, long after the point where a visitor decides whether to keep going.
There is no route by recipient, occasion, budget or gift type. The page shows products but never asks who the gift is for, so a visitor has to work out the catalogue on their own.
The mugs collection offers a sort by best selling or alphabetical order and nothing else. There is no way to narrow by recipient, size or style, so the page reads like a catalogue rather than a guide.
Sorting by best selling returns the whole collection, and every mug carries a discount. With no visual cues to separate products, the labels stop meaning anything and comparison becomes impossible.
Each mug card shows an image, a name and a price. All are listed as ceramic with no sizes stated, so a visitor has to open every product page to learn the basics that should help them choose.
There is no social proof anywhere on the site. The product page has a reviews button, but clicking it shows nothing, which is worse than having no button at all.
The product page offers a standard box and a luxury box without saying what makes the luxury box different, and choosing the standard box means scrolling back down past everything to see the result.
Only 30 left, eight people buying, a countdown to a delivery date and secure checkout notes all sit on the page, but they are scattered pieces, and the emoji in the urgency line undercuts a professional store.
After the add to cart button the page shows related products and nothing more. There is no gift wrap, no message card, no pairing and no reason to add a second item, so leaving is as easy as buying.
State what the store sells, who it is for and why it can be trusted in the first screen. Replace the stock photo with the gifts themselves and make the gifting purpose unmistakable in the headline.
Show a star rating and review count next to the headline so the first thing a visitor learns is that other people have bought here and been happy. This is the single fastest trust signal the site lacks.
Lift the delivery, returns and money back reassurances from the footer into a bar directly beneath the hero, where they answer the hesitation at the moment it forms.
Run a thin bar above the header stating that orders ship within one business day with an arrival estimate, plus a free shipping progress line such as you are a set amount away from free shipping.
Replace the flat menu with routes for her, for him, by occasion, by budget and by gift type so a shopper can pick the path that matches how they already think about buying a gift.
Add a finder that asks who the gift is for, the occasion, the message for the card, the gift type, the budget and the date needed, then recommends a short set of matching products.
Below the hero, give three guided sections in that order: start with the person, then shop by occasion such as birthday or Mother's Day, then shop by gift type such as mugs or journals.
Pick a few genuine bestsellers and show each with the engraved saying, name, a one line description, a review rating, the two box options and a visible plus button to add to cart without opening the page.
Add a comparison chart showing why buying here beats Amazon, Temu or other gifting sites, covering the hand boxed gift, the message card, delivery and the guarantee.
Add a reviews section with customer images, a someone here boxes your gift by hand section, and a how we ship section so the visitor can picture what arrives and who prepared it.
Add a never miss her birthday section where a visitor can set a reminder and pick a gift ahead of time, giving a reason to return even if they do not buy today.
Start the mugs collection with a short intro stating that every gift comes with a message, and that mugs are available as 11 oz and 15 oz ceramic and insulated camping mugs, so basics are clear before browsing.
Let shoppers filter by recipient, show badges such as for daughter or for anyone, and give each card a description, price and rating so products can be compared without opening each one.
Replace the all on sale approach with a pair it with section offering a journal, a second mug or wrap with a personalised message, giving a reason for a discount only when the order grows.
Put the rating under the product name, follow with price and a short description, and show the standard and premium box as image thumbnails so the choice is visible without scrolling.
Add a gift wrap and personal message option at seven dollars beside the cart button, with a field for the note, so the emotional part of the purchase also raises the order value.
Bring the arrival date, the delivery and returns guarantees and the secure checkout note into a single tidy block under the add to cart, and drop the emoji from the urgency line.
Offer a choose three and get free shipping bundle below the fold, then close with will it fit, will it last reassurances and a questions before you buy section that handles the last objections.
A concept redesign of Above The Rest, a US store selling message-themed gifts: necklaces, watches, bracelets, blankets, journals, mugs and plaques, each with words written for one person. Homepage, mega menu, gift finder, collection, product page and cart, built from the findings of a conversion audit of the live store. Nobody buys a necklace here. A dad buys the words "I'm proud of you" for his daughter, and the necklace is how they arrive. The live store presents like a product feed: every card wears the same sale badge, the free-shipping bar reads "Spend $x", the urgency widget and the delivery estimate render with blanks, and the Reviews tab opens on nothing. The product page asks for a finish and a box before it shows what the card says or what the box looks like. The navigation has the right three paths, by recipient, occasion and gift type, but none of them guides anyone, and the Birthday collection holds almost the whole catalogue. Most single-item orders land just under the free-shipping line, and the gift wrap that would carry them over sits as a separate product nobody is offered. We made the store ask before it shows. The homepage opens on the box with the card visible and one button, Find their gift, then routes by person, occasion and gift type, with the USA story told as three steps and a place for giver reviews and unboxing photos. The mega menu gives each path its own panel with the finder one tap away. A six-question Gift Finder takes who it is for, the occasion, what the card should say, the kind of gift, the budget and the date, and returns three picks with the card message in full, the box choice and an arrive-by line. The collection gets a one-line intro, chips, real filters and cards that carry the recipient, the size and the delivery date. The product page leads with the card and the box, puts delivery and the guarantee under the button, offers gift wrap with a personal note at the point of decision, and replaces the alphabetical related list with gifts matched to the same recipient. The cart shows the free-shipping progress and the wrap, and the phone screens keep the button pinned. Every screen uses the store's own product photography and voice.
A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.
The whole page in two columns: the open box and the words in the first screen, the proof ribbon, start with the person, shop by occasion, shop by gift type and the most-given gifts; then the comparison with marketplaces, the giver stories, the USA story, the birthday reminder and the footer.
The homepage in the centre, the product page's buy column on the left with its finish and box choices, Add to cart and the four reasons to buy here, the Mugs collection on the right with its banner, chip row and filter column. One system across every page.
A slide-over, not a page: the free-shipping bar at the top, one line per gift with its finish, box or size and a short giver quote, then the subtotal, the ships-by line with the money-back guarantee, Review & check out and the payment marks.
Who is it for, what's the occasion, what do you want it to say, what kind of gift, what's your budget, when do you need it, then three picks for that person and that day: our pick, a keepsake and a little extra, each with the card message in full and an arrive-by line.
The whole page in two columns: gallery and buy box, the card printed in full, the fit and care answers, reviews with the opened box, why buy here, the gifts that complete this one, the questions before you buy and the footer.
Thumbnail rail and hero photo, recipient tag, title, review line and price, finish swatches, the box choice with the luxury box as a priced upgrade, gift wrap with a note as a tick box, Add to cart, the four perks, the ships-by and arrives-by lines, payment marks and the Gift Finder link.
Breadcrumb, the dark Mugs banner with one line on sizes and materials, the chip row by type and recipient, the filter column by recipient, occasion and product type, the Showing and Sort row, and the first row of cards with a recipient tag, sizes, the price and the arrival date.
For Her and For Him with four columns, two tiles and the most-given pieces; Occasions with a short-on-time column for late buyers; Gift Type with starting prices and two easy first gifts; Best Sellers as one short edit. Every panel ends on the finder strip.
The first screen with the box and Find their gift, the Mugs collection with the quick-add sheet open over it, and the product page with its pinned Add to cart bar. One thumb, one decision at a time.
Above The Rest is a Shopify gift store selling engraved mugs, journals and boxed gifts. Products can be ordered in a standard or luxury box and posted directly to the recipient. Our CRO strategist noted that most products are assembled and shipped from the USA.
The site never establishes trust or direction. The hero shows a logo and a stock photo rather than stating what the store does and who it is for, and there are no customer reviews anywhere on the site. Without those two things a visitor hesitates before they ever reach a product.
Because the products themselves are attractive and the gifting model is sound. Our CRO strategist called out the mug range in particular. The weakness is the presentation layer, which does not help a visitor discover the right gift, trust the store, or follow a path to checkout.
If every product is discounted, no discount gives a reason to choose one item over another, and the sale badge stops meaning anything. The audit found the same issue with bestseller labels, where sorting by best selling returned the entire mugs collection. The redesign uses discounts only for pairing or bundling.
The mugs collection shows an image, a name and a price per card, with no sizes and no filters beyond a basic sort. Every mug is marked as reduced and as a bestseller, and there are no trust signals on the page. The proposed version adds an intro, filters, badges, descriptive cards and a pair it with section.
Partly. It already has stock counts, a delivery countdown, secure checkout messaging and reasons to buy, which the audit describes as kind of working. But the box options are unexplained, the urgency line uses an emoji, the reviews button opens nothing and the only next step is a list of related products.
It is a short guided flow on the homepage that asks who the gift is for, the occasion, the message for the card, the gift type, the budget and the date needed, then recommends a handful of products. The audit describes it as the digital version of a shop assistant who asks what you are looking for.
Through gift wrap with a personal message offered at the add to cart, a pair it with section on the collection page, and a choose three and get free shipping bundle on the product page. The idea is to give a discount only when the order grows rather than marking everything down by default.
Directly under the hero rather than in the footer. The proposed homepage shows a review rating in the hero, then a bar covering delivery, reviews, returns and the money back guarantee, and repeats reassurances near every add to cart button so they appear at each point of hesitation.
No. The recording does not state traffic, revenue or conversion rate for Above The Rest. It points to a revenue calculator on the Convertica Studio site where an owner can enter their own visitor numbers and average order value to see what a change in conversion rate would mean.
Two routes. The owner can make the changes themselves, which the audit notes tends to take months of small edits, or they can schedule a call with Convertica Studio to discuss timeline, scope and investment. The recording mentions that the studio prices well below what agencies typically charge for this kind of setup.
The recording runs 37 minutes. It audits the homepage, the mugs collection page and a product page of Above The Rest, then walks through proposed redesigns of all three pages and closes with the revenue calculator and next steps.
Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.
Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.
