Problem, opportunity, impact
Core Problem
The website has a warm brand feel, but it moves too quickly into product selling, overuses sale pricing, and does not use trust, reviews, sizing reassurance, or emotional storytelling strongly enough.
Main Oppurtunity
Position Luna Leash as a family-owned, made-in-Ohio dog apparel brand that helps dog parents find shirts based on their dog’s personality while increasing trust and average order value.
Estimated Impact
Stronger trust, clearer product discovery, better size confidence, fewer checkout surprises, higher conversion rate, and increased average order value through bundles and personality-based shopping.
Core Problem
This audit found that Luna Leash already has a warm, joyful brand feeling, which is better than many standard Shopify catalog-style websites. The tone feels friendly, pet-focused, and emotionally relevant.
The main issue is that the website moves too quickly into selling products before fully building trust. The homepage should first establish credibility, explain the brand story, show proof, and emotionally connect with dog parents before showing product grids.
Another major issue is the overuse of discounts. Because nearly every product appears to be on sale, the sale loses meaning and can reduce trust. A better approach would be to use fewer strategic discounts and focus more on free shipping, guarantees, product quality, and bundles.
The collection page currently feels like a product dump instead of a guided shopping experience. Luna Leash has a strong opportunity to organize products by dog personality, such as boss of the house, mama’s shadow, tiny tornado, or sweet and sentimental.
The product page has a decent foundation, but it needs stronger visible reviews, better trust messaging near the add-to-cart button, clearer size guidance, free shipping reassurance, and stronger cross-sell or bundle sections to increase average order value.
Problems Identified
Top Bar Focuses Too Quickly On Sale
The first message users see is buy four shirts and get one free. This jumps into selling before building trust.
Hero Section Is Underused
The hero image and message create a warm feeling, but the section does not fully explain the brand, build trust, or guide visitors.
Hero Image Quality Could Be Better
The main hero image appears low resolution and does not maximize the most valuable real estate on the website.
Trust Proof Is Buried Too Low
The strongest proof, such as being trusted by thousands of dog owners, appears too late on the page.
Emojis Reduce Professional Trust
Using smileys or emojis can make sections feel AI-generated or less polished. Proper icons would feel more credible.
Products Appear Too Early
The homepage moves into product grids before enough story, trust, and emotional connection are built.
Everything Appears To Be On Sale
When every product is on sale, the discount loses meaning and may make users feel the pricing is artificial.
Sale Strategy Hurts Trust
Showing a crossed-out price on every product can feel like the price was raised just to show a discount.
Collection Page Feels Like A Product Dump
The collection page lists products but does not guide users based on dog personality, occasion, gift intent, or product type.
Collection Page Does Not Help Decision-Making
Users have to scan through too many products without enough filters, cues, or buying guidance.
Reviews Are Not Visible Enough On Product Page
The product has reviews, but they are not prominent enough near the decision area.
Shipping Calculated At Checkout Creates Friction
Shipping calculated at checkout creates uncertainty and can feel like a surprise cost waiting at checkout.
Product Page Needs A Stronger Reason To Buy
The product title and price are visible, but the page does not clearly explain the emotional value or outcome of buying the shirt.
Trust Messaging Is Too Far From Add To Cart
Guarantees, exchanges, shipping, and reassurance should appear near the add-to-cart button where the decision happens.
Average Order Value Is Underused
The product page ends too quickly and misses opportunities to sell bundles, matching collars, multiple shirts, or complete wardrobes.
Recommendations
Use The Top Bar For Trust
Lead with messages such as made to order in Ohio, free U.S. shipping, family owned, or one-year guarantee before pushing sales.
Strengthen The Hero Section
Use a more emotional headline such as dog shirts made for the dogs who make every day better.
Show Trust Above The Fold
Add trust signals such as family-owned, made in Ohio, one-year guarantee, fast shipping, and thousands of happy dog parents.
Introduce The Luna Story Early
Tell the story of Luna and explain that the brand treats customers’ dogs like family.
Replace Emojis With Proper Icons
Use clean icons instead of smileys to make trust sections feel more polished and intentional.
Move Social Proof Higher
Bring customer reviews, happy dog parent quotes, and trust proof closer to the top of the homepage.
Stop Showing Every Product On Sale
Use sale pricing only for selected hero products and let other products appear at regular price.
Use Free Shipping Instead Of Fake-Looking Discounts
Instead of discounting every product, keep pricing cleaner and promote free shipping as the value driver.
Create Personality-Based Shopping
Organize products by dog personality such as tiny tornado, mama’s shadow, boss of the house, sassy and statement, or sweet and sentimental.
Improve Collection Page Filtering
Let users filter by dog personality, gift type, sentiment, funny shirts, custom shirts, and best sellers.
Add Visual Product Cues
Use badges like best seller, most gifted, new, custom, or fan favorite to help users decide faster.
Make Reviews Prominent On Product Pages
Show review stars and review count near the product title and price so users see trust before buying.
Remove Shipping Surprise
Replace shipping calculated at checkout with clear free shipping or shipping threshold messaging.
Add A Short Emotional Product Description
Explain what the product does emotionally, such as making the dog’s personality visible or turning everyday walks into compliment moments.
Place Trust Near Add To Cart
Add one-year guarantee, easy exchange, fast U.S. shipping, and secure checkout near the purchase button.
Improve Size Confidence
Add a clearer size guide and reassurance that exchanges are easy if the size is wrong.
Remove Social Share Buttons
Remove share, tweet, and pin buttons because they add distraction and are rarely used.
Add Bundle Offers
Promote buy four, get one free directly on product pages where purchase decisions happen.
Cross-Sell Matching Products
Add matching collars, additional shirts, or complete-the-look recommendations to increase average order value.
Add FAQs For SEO And LLM Search
Add product-specific FAQs around sizing, shipping, exchanges, materials, washing, and personalization to improve search and AI answer visibility.
The short version
- Luna Leash already has a warm and joyful brand feel.
- The homepage should build trust before showing products.
- The sale strategy should be simplified because everything on sale reduces trust.
- Free shipping may be more persuasive than discounting every product.
- Customer proof should appear much higher on the page.
- The collection page should guide shoppers by dog personality.
- Product reviews should be more visible near the buying area.
- Shipping calculated at checkout can hurt conversion.
- Size guidance and easy exchanges can reduce hesitation.
- Bundles, matching collars, and buy-four-get-one offers can increase average order value.
Before
After
Before
After
(Free CRO audit)
See what's quietly
costing you sales.
Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video
showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.
Tell Us About Your Store
Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.
What's Included
5-minute video teardown
4:52
Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
.webp){kind=small}
.webp){kind=small}
