Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Florist, Gifts & Home Fragrance

Mad Lilies CRO Audit

A conversion teardown of the Mad Lilies home page, bath and body collection page and recycled green glass product page, with a clickable redesign concept for the flowers, gifts and wedding range.

13
Issues found
15
Fixes proposed
29
Minutes of tape
4.6
Overall / 10
29 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 29-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

Mad Lilies sells a broad and attractive range: fresh flowers, gifts, cards, candles, bath and body, plants, Christmas lines and ready to wear and custom wedding dresses. The photography looks good, the navigation is already organised by department, collections have filters, and reviews appear on the home page. Most of the ingredients of a converting store are already there.

The core problem is the presentation layer, not the products. The hero section shows flowers but does not say what the business does best, who it is for, or why other people trust it. A visitor has to work out the shop alone, and the wedding range stays hidden until they scroll a long way down the home page, so hesitation sets in early.

The same gap repeats lower down. Collection pages show a plain grid where two hand and body washes at the same price look identical, so shoppers must open each page to compare. On the recycled green glass product page, reviews are missing near the buy button, the description is long, and delivery, returns and shipping cost are left vague.

The direction is to make the site behave like the shop floor. Ask the visitor how to help, offer guided paths for flowers, gifts and weddings, put the differences on the product cards, and answer delivery, returns and reviews beside the button. Remove the reasons not to buy and only the reasons to buy remain. Treat the site as a salesperson, not a catalogue.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The site has a lovely range but behaves like a catalogue. The hero does not say who it is for or why to trust it, and the product page leaves delivery, returns and reasons to buy unanswered at the key moment.

Main opportunity

Mad Lilies could work online like the helpful shop assistant it already has in person, asking what the visitor needs, guiding them to flowers, gifts or wedding wear, and answering every doubt before add to cart.

Estimated impact

Visitors who already arrive would find the right product faster, trust the store sooner and add more to each order, so existing traffic and ad spend would turn into more completed purchases.

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

4.6 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
3 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 7/10
UX 5/10
Trust 4/10
Product Page 3/10
Conversion 4/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

13 issues found, 15 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Hero Does Not Say Who It Is For

The home page hero shows flowers but never states what the business does best, who it serves or why anyone should trust it. A new visitor has to guess, and hesitation starts in the first few seconds.

No Trust Signals Above The Fold

Reviews exist on the home page, but not where a first time visitor expects to see them. Nothing near the hero tells a stranger that other people have bought from Mad Lilies and been happy.

Best Sellers Appear Too Early

The home page pushes best sellers almost immediately, like a shop assistant recommending a product before asking what the customer wants. Visitors who came for something else have no route to it.

Wedding Range Hidden From Navigation

Ready to wear and custom wedding dresses are a strong offer, but they are absent from the navigation and only appear far down the home page. Visitors who do not scroll never learn they exist.

Navigation Offers Departments, Not Journeys

The navigation is tidy and organised by department, but it does not guide shoppers by occasion, recipient, price or delivery. Someone with a gift in mind has to browse rather than be led.

Home Page Offers No Guided Buying Paths

There is no equivalent of the question a shop assistant asks at the door. Nothing asks whether the visitor wants flowers, gifts or plants, or helps them narrow down what they need.

Collection Pages Behave Like A Catalogue

The bath and body collection is a grid of products with filters. It shows what is available but does not help the shopper decide what to buy or point to the right choice.

Product Cards Hide The Differences

Two hand and body washes from the same brand sit at the same price and look identical in the grid. Without key details on the card, shoppers must open each product page just to compare.

No Reviews Near The Buy Button

On the recycled green glass product page there are no reviews around the decision making button. Storewide reviews could fill the gap, but nothing currently reassures the buyer at that moment.

No Reason To Buy From Mad Lilies

The product page never explains why this item should be bought from this shop. There is no case made for the brand, the quality or the choice, so the purchase is left unjustified.

Long Description Is Hard To Scan

The product description is long and dense. A buyer deciding quickly cannot pick out the few facts that matter, so the page asks for effort rather than helping the decision.

Delivery And Returns Left Unanswered

The only shipping note is that taxes are included and shipping is calculated at checkout. Arrival time, delivery cost and what happens if something goes wrong are not answered on the page.

No Prompt To Raise Order Value

The product page offers no free delivery incentive, add on or bundle. Nothing encourages one buyer to take a second item, so each order stays as small as the first product.

Recommendations

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

State what Mad Lilies does, who it is for and why it can be trusted within the first screen. Place a short line and a few customer reviews in the hero so a stranger is reassured at once.

Add Shop Flowers And Find A Gift Buttons

Replace the passive hero with two clear calls to action that ask how you can help. One leads to flowers and one to gifts, mirroring the question asked at the door of the physical shop.

Build A Short Gift Finder Quiz

Ask who the gift is for, the delivery date, the budget and the taste, then show matching products and a ready made bundle. This turns a hesitant gift buyer into someone with a shortlist.

Reorganise Navigation By Type, Moment And Price

Group flowers by type, moment and delivery, and gifts by recipient, occasion and price bands. Shoppers with a budget or occasion in mind can reach the right products straight from the menu.

Put Wedding Wear And Florals In The Navigation

Add weddings as its own menu item covering wedding wear and florals, so the dress range is visible without scrolling. Repeat it later in a home page section with consultation and shop options.

Move Best Sellers Below The Guided Paths

Let visitors choose a path first, then show best sellers and most loved items as a fallback. This keeps the recommendation for people who have not yet found what they were looking for.

Add Category Funnels For Occasions

Create entry points for birthday, thank you, sympathy, new home and get well soon, each leading to a curated set. Occasion shoppers then land on products already chosen for their need.

Show Key Details On Every Product Card

Add a badge, a clear image, the size or contents, a rating and a one line difference to each card. Shoppers can then tell the two hand and body washes apart without opening either page.

Add Quick Toggles And A Finder To Collections

Give collection pages buttons such as gift, under a set price, hand and bath, plus a finder at the top. Extend the filters to scent family, brand, gift ready and rating.

Place Reviews Around The Add To Cart Button

Show review stars and a short quote beside the price and again near the button. Where a product has none, reuse storewide reviews so buyers see that others have bought and were happy.

Explain Why To Buy From Mad Lilies

Add a short section on the product page that gives the reasons to buy this item here, covering quality, the shop behind it and the pricing. Keep it to a few points a buyer can scan.

Shorten The Description Into Scannable Points

Cut the long description to the few facts that decide the purchase, such as size, what is included and what it is made from. Move any extra detail into a collapsible section.

Answer Delivery And Returns On The Page

Show when the item will arrive, what delivery costs, who gets free delivery and how returns work, next to the price. Repeat the key points in a short FAQ so no doubt is left.

Add A Free Delivery Bar With A Matching Add On

Show how far the basket is from free delivery and suggest an item, such as a diffuser, that closes the gap. Pair it with a bundle so one buyer takes two products.

Add Gift Options At The Cart Button

Let gift buyers add a card note, choose gift wrap and hide prices without leaving the product page. This removes a step for the visitors most likely to spend more.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.

Homepage in two tall columns

The first column opens on the hero and categories, the second runs through to the footer.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Homepage, two tall columns

Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Three pages side by side: the product page on the left, the homepage in the centre and a collection page on the right.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Basket slide over open over the product page, whole screen

The basket slide-over open over the product page, shown whole from top to bottom with the page dimmed behind it.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Basket slide over open over the product page, whole screen

Gift Finder quiz, step by step

The Gift Finder quiz, step by step: who it is for, the moment, the postcode, the budget and their taste, ending on a finished gift set.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Gift Finder quiz, step by step

Product page, two tall columns

The product page in two tall columns, from the photos and buy box down to the footer.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Product page, two tall columns

Product page first screen: header and buy box

The product page first screen: header, photos and the buy box with sizes, button and delivery lines.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Product page first screen: header and buy box

Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

A collection page first screen with the banner, filters and the first row of product cards with prices.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

Mega menu, every panel open

The mega menu, one panel per nav item: Flowers, Gifts, Cards & Wrap, Home & Garden, Candles & Fragrance, Christmas, Plants and Weddings & Events.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Mega menu, every panel open

Search, the bar and the results

Search: the bar with quick suggestions, then the results with filters and product cards.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Search, the bar and the results

Three phone screens: home, collection, product

Three phone screens, staggered: home, collection and product.

Mad Lilies concept redesign: Three phone screens: home, collection, product
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • The products are not the problem; the way they are presented is what holds conversions back.
  • A home page hero must tell a stranger what the shop does, who it is for and why to trust it within seconds.
  • A website should behave like a good shop assistant and ask how it can help before it recommends anything.
  • If the wedding dresses cannot be found without scrolling, most visitors will never know they are for sale.
  • A collection page that only shows a grid describes what is available but not what to buy.
  • Product cards should carry enough detail that two similar items can be told apart without opening either page.
  • The product page exists to handle objections, so reviews, delivery, returns and reasons to buy belong beside the button.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

The biggest issue is not weak products or low traffic. It is the presentation layer, which does not help visitors discover the right product or feel confident enough to buy. The hero, collection pages and product page all leave key questions unanswered.

A visitor should learn what the business does, who it is for and whether others trust it within the first few seconds. The current hero shows flowers but does not say these things, so hesitation starts before the visitor has seen any products.

Ready to wear and custom wedding dresses are a distinct and valuable offer. Today they only appear after a long scroll, so anyone who does not scroll that far never learns they exist. A menu item makes the whole range clear at once.

In a physical shop, staff ask what you are looking for and then lead you to flowers, gifts or plants. A website can do the same with clear buttons, a short gift finder and guided paths, rather than showing best sellers straight away.

The filters help, but the grid itself behaves like a catalogue. Two hand and body washes at the same price look identical, so shoppers must open each page to find the difference. Cards need badges, contents, ratings and a clear point of difference.

That is the moment a careful buyer decides whether to spend money. Reviews on the home page do not help there. If a product has none, storewide reviews can be reused to show that people have bought from the shop and were satisfied.

It should say when the item will arrive, what delivery costs, whether there is free delivery for UK customers and what happens if something goes wrong. Currently the page only notes that shipping is calculated at checkout.

Show how close the basket is to free delivery and suggest a matching add on, such as a diffuser. Bundles that pair flowers, a card and a gift item also encourage one buyer to take two products instead of one.

The recommendation is to fix the site first. Ads already bring people who know the business, and each extra visitor is worth more once the site converts better. Sending more traffic to the current pages simply repeats the same leaks.

No. The concept is a clickable prototype built in Figma to show the strategy for the home page, a collection page and a product page. It illustrates how the presentation could change and is not the final visual design.

No. The audit is about conversion, not a makeover. Many of the right elements are already on the site, such as reviews, filters and a good navigation structure. The work is mostly about placement, clarity and a few additions.

The video reviews the Mad Lilies home page, the bath and body collection page and the recycled green glass product page, then walks through a clickable redesign concept. The recording runs for 29 minutes.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.