Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Original Paintings & Art Prints

Maureen Jones CRO Audit

A page by page CRO audit of Maureen Jones, a Shopify store selling original paintings and prints, covering the homepage, collection page and product page, plus a redesign concept built for conversion.

12
Issues found
14
Fixes proposed
29
Minutes of tape
3.6
Overall / 10
29 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 29-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

Maureen Jones sells original handmade paintings and prints, and the work itself is not the weak point. The catalog is broad, covering wildlife, florals, abstract and whimsical subjects. The store also gives delivery information and offers price sorting on the collection page, so the foundations of a considered shop are already there.

The core problem is that the presentation layer is fragmented. A visitor lands on a hero that does not say who the art is for or whether other collectors trust the shop, then scrolls past a grid of images, names and prices. Nothing says where to go next, so the store behaves like an inventory list and leaves the visitor to do every job alone.

The same gap repeats further down. Collection cards show only an image, a name and a price, so shoppers must open many product pages to compare. The product page has no reviews, no painting dimensions and no returns or condition information, and its You May Also Like block hands the choice back to the visitor. Nothing pairs pieces to lift order value.

The direction is a guided gallery. Navigation by subject, room, price and gifting, a short painting finder, richer cards, reviews, size and returns answers and paired pieces replace the catalog feel. The visitor already arrives with intent, and the site's job is to turn that intent into a sale. Buying should never be the visitor's job to figure out.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The site behaves like a catalog. Visitors see paintings, names and prices but get no guided path, no reviews and no dimensions, so each buyer must work out alone whether a piece is right for their home.

Main opportunity

Turn the catalog into a guided gallery: a painting finder, navigation by subject, room and price, comparable product cards, visible reviews and paired pieces that help a visitor with real intent reach a decision.

Estimated impact

More of the visitors already arriving should feel confident enough to buy, and orders should grow in value through paired paintings. Conversion improves as hesitation falls, without needing extra traf

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

3.6 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
4 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 6/10
UX 4/10
Trust 2/10
Product Page 3/10
Conversion 3/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

12 issues found, 14 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Hero Does Not Answer Core Questions

The homepage hero signals original art by feel alone. It does not say who the paintings are for or whether other collectors trust the shop, so a first time visitor has to guess.

Trust Signals Are Missing Sitewide

There are no reviews, no happy customer evidence and no sign that people have bought before. For paintings priced up to around 175, that leaves the safety of buying unanswered.

Homepage Offers No Guided Buying Paths

Scrolling the homepage gives a run of paintings with names and prices but no direction on where to go next or which piece suits the visitor. It behaves like an inventory.

Art Browsing Routes Are Not Obvious

Collectors expect to browse by category, subject or bestsellers, such as wildlife or florals. That structure is not offered on the homepage, so exploring takes effort.

Collection Sorting Is Only Standard Shopify

The price sorting is a good start, but below it the sorting is the default Shopify set. There are few categories and no richer ways to narrow a large range of paintings.

Collection Cards Show Too Little Detail

Cards show an image, a name and a price. Shoppers cannot compare pieces without opening many product pages, and many will leave in frustration before finding the right one.

Product Page Has No Customer Reviews

Reviews are absent across the whole site and the gap costs most on the product page, where the decision is made. Nothing shows that buying is safe or that buyers are satisfied.

Painting Dimensions Are Not Shown

Without dimensions, a buyer cannot picture the piece on their wall or judge whether it is small or large. Size is a core question for any artwork and it goes unanswered.

Returns And Condition Are Not Explained

Delivery is covered, which helps, but returns and the condition the painting arrives in are not. Those are the questions that tend to decide a hesitant buyer.

Related Products Leave The Choice Open

The You May Also Like block hands the decision back to the visitor. It gives no reason to choose one piece over another and does not help complete a room.

No Attempt To Raise Order Value

Nothing pairs paintings or builds a look for a living room or lounge. A visitor who likes cats is not shown a matching jungle or tiger piece, so each order stays at one painting.

Wall Preview Link Does Not Work

A wall preview option appears on the product page, but clicking it does nothing and never asks the visitor to add an image. They are left lost at a key moment.

Recommendations

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

State what the shop sells, who the paintings are for and why collectors trust it, with signed, original and free UK postage packed by the artist visible at first glance.

Add A Find My Piece Painting Finder

Place a short question flow in the hero asking about room, mood and budget, then recommend matching paintings, like a gallery host asking how they can help.

Organise Navigation By Subject Room And Price

Build menus for originals and prints by subject, room, price and size, with separate gifts and artist sections, so every visitor can start from the route that suits them.

Introduce A Gifting Section

Add gifts organised by recipient, budget and occasion, with gift ready pieces, so shoppers buying for someone else are given a path and a reason to buy.

Add Reviews And Collector Photos Sitewide

Show star ratings on cards and product pages, and add a collector section with real photos of paintings in homes alongside what buyers say about them.

Group Collections By Subject With Bestsellers

Add collections such as abstract, whimsical and fantasy, and floral and nature, plus bestseller, customer favourite and staff pick rows, so browsing has clear entry points.

Expand Collection Filters And Sorting

Offer filters for subject, medium, price, size, framing, palette and orientation, with a short description and piece count at the top of each collection.

Make Product Cards Self Explanatory

Add badges such as gift ready, bestseller and limited edition, plus ratings and the key facts needed to compare, so shoppers can decide without opening every page.

Show Dimensions And A Size Guide

State painting sizes clearly on every product page and add a size guide, so buyers can judge how a piece fits their wall before they commit.

Answer Returns Condition And Care Questions

Add clear returns terms, a certified original note, secure checkout, how the painting is packed, and care and hanging advice close to the buy button.

Fix And Expand The Wall Preview Tool

Make the preview work and let visitors add a photo of their own wall, so they can see how a piece looks in their room before they buy.

Offer Original Print And Frame Options

Let buyers choose the original, an unframed print or a framed print on one page, with gift wrap and a gift note, and explain the honest difference between them.

Pair Paintings To Complete The Look

Offer pre built pairs that complete a wall, such as a cat painting with a jungle piece, and add a progress bar toward a free express upgrade to lift order value.

Add Artwork Stories FAQs And An Enquiry Route

Tell the story behind each piece to justify its price, add answers to common questions, and give offices and clients an enquiry option for something customised.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.

Homepage, two tall columns

Homepage in two tall columns: the first screens on the left, the run down to the footer on the right.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Homepage, two tall columns

Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Three pages side by side: the product page, the homepage and a collection page.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

The bag slide-over open over the product page, so the whole drawer is visible from top to bottom.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

Find your painting quiz, step by step

The Find Your Painting quiz, step by step: who it is for, where it will hang, the feeling and the budget, ending on matches shown on a bedroom wall.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Find your painting quiz, step by step

Product page, two tall columns

The product page in two tall columns, with the buy box whole on the left and the footer on the right.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Product page, two tall columns

Product page first screen: header and buy box

The product page first screen: header, gallery and the buy box with format choices, price and delivery.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Product page first screen: header and buy box

Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

The collection page first screen: header, filters and the first row of paintings.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

Mega menu, every panel open

The mega menu, one screen per nav item: Originals, Prints, Gifts, For Interiors, The Artist and Journal.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Mega menu, every panel open

Search: the bar and the matching paintings

Search: a word typed in the bar and matching paintings appearing under it with price and subject.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Search: the bar and the matching paintings

Three phone screens: home, collection, product

Three phone screens: home, collection and product, staggered left to right.

Maureen Jones concept redesign: Three phone screens: home, collection, product
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • The biggest opportunity here is not more traffic, it is helping the visitors already arriving feel confident enough to buy.
  • A store that shows only images, names and prices behaves like an inventory, and leaves the visitor to do every job alone.
  • A homepage hero should answer what the business does, who it is for and whether other people trust it.
  • When a painting costs up to around 175, the purchase is a real decision, so reviews, dimensions and returns are not optional.
  • A painting finder works like a gallery host asking how they can help, then recommending a short list of pieces.
  • Collection cards should carry enough detail that a shopper can compare pieces without opening every product page.
  • Pairing paintings to complete a room puts two artworks in one order instead of one.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

The paintings are strong and visitors already arrive with intent. The site does not help them decide, so adding traffic would send more people into the same hesitation. Fixing confidence and guidance first makes every later visitor worth more.

Visitors see a grid of paintings with names and prices, and nothing more. There is no suggestion of where to go next or which piece suits them. A guided store narrows the choice for the visitor.

Original paintings are a considered purchase, and a buyer needs proof that others have bought safely and been happy. The site currently shows no reviews anywhere, so the question of whether it is safe to buy goes unanswered.

It should say what the shop sells, who it is for and why collectors can trust it. Signals such as signed originals and free UK postage, packed by the artist, answer those questions quickly. Two clear buttons then point the visitor onward.

It asks a few short questions, such as the room, the mood and the budget, and recommends matching pieces. That mirrors a gallery host helping a visitor in person. The shopper gets a short list instead of a long grid.

Each card should show a clear image, the name, the price, a rating and badges such as bestseller or gift ready. It should also carry the key facts needed to compare. This lets shoppers choose without opening many pages.

Reviews, painting dimensions, and information on returns and the condition a painting arrives in are all missing. Delivery is already covered, which is a good base to build on. A working wall preview would also help buyers picture the piece at home.

By pairing paintings that complete a room, such as a cat painting with a jungle piece, and by showing pre built pairs. A progress bar toward a free express upgrade can also encourage a second item. The aim is two paintings for one buyer.

Many visitors may be buying for someone else, or could be nudged to. Gifts organised by recipient, budget and occasion give them a path. It also plants the idea of gifting in visitors who came for themselves.

No. The paintings and the artist's identity stay at the centre. The redesign changes how the pieces are presented, organised and explained, and adds an artist section that tells the story behind the work.

The recording quotes a timeline of four weeks for the full project. It also outlines lighter options, including improving the three existing pages or installing the conversion focused theme independently. The next step suggested is a strategy call.

The audit reviews the homepage, the collection page and the product page of the current site, then walks through a redesign concept for each. It also covers a revenue calculator, project options and next steps. The video runs for 29 minutes.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.