Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Handmade Gold Plated Jewellery

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery CRO Audit

A teardown of a Shopify jewellery store covering its homepage, ear studs collection page and necklace product page, with a conversion focused redesign concept for each page.

12
Issues found
14
Fixes proposed
23
Minutes of tape
4.6
Overall / 10
23 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 23-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

The store already has the hardest part in place. The jewellery photographs well, the catalogue is organised by category, and the products look good. The homepage shows products early, the collection pages have clear names and descriptions, and reviews already exist on every page type. The necklace page even tries to raise basket size, which few stores do.

The core problem is the presentation layer, not the products. A first time visitor can tell this is a jewellery store, but not who it is for, why it can be trusted or when an order would arrive. The hero offers free delivery and little else, and nothing invites the visitor to say what they are looking for. Hesitation starts on the first screen.

The same gap repeats further down the funnel. The homepage behaves like a list of names and prices, and the navigation hides its contents until it is opened. On the ear studs page, comparing four products means opening four pages. On the necklace page, a long description and missing returns and checkout cost details leave questions open at the moment of decision.

The direction is a guided buying experience. Ask what the visitor needs, show clear paths by category, occasion, budget and recipient, put the key facts on the product cards, and answer delivery, returns and care on the product page. Offer pairs and bundles from the first screen. A good online jewellery store should behave like a good shop assistant.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The presentation layer leaves visitors to work out where to start. Pages read like a catalogue, with few guided paths, thin trust signals in the hero and product details that need extra clicks.

Main opportunity

Turn the store from a catalogue into a guided shop, with a finder, clear paths by occasion, budget and recipient, scannable product cards and a product page that answers every question before checkout.

Estimated impact

Visitors reach the right product faster, compare pieces without opening many pages, and meet fewer unanswered questions at Add to Cart. The result is more confident buyers and larger baskets.

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

4.6 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
3 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 6/10
UX 4/10
Trust 4/10
Product Page 5/10
Conversion 4/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

12 issues found, 14 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Hero Does Not Say Who It Is For

The homepage looks like a jewellery store, but the first screen does not say who the pieces are for or what the shopper is meant to do next. The visitor has to decide alone whether this store suits them.

Trust Signals Missing From The Hero

Reviews exist on the site, but the first screen carries no rating, no maker story and no sign that other buyers trust the brand. Trust is built too late, if the visitor scrolls far enough to find it.

Delivery Promise Lacks Timing And Origin Detail

Free delivery on all orders is stated, but not when an order will arrive, where the pieces are made or who makes them. These are the first questions a gift buyer has about jewellery.

Homepage Behaves Like A Catalogue

Scrolling the homepage shows product after product with a name and a price, and little else. It works like a shop that points at stock the moment someone walks in, before asking what they want.

No Guided Buying Paths For Exploration

There are no clear routes by earrings, necklaces, bracelets, ear studs, occasion, budget or recipient. A visitor who is unsure what to buy has no way to narrow the range.

Navigation Hides Its Contents Until Opened

The menu gives no hint of how many collections exist or how they are organised. Visitors must open every menu to learn what the store sells, which adds effort before any browsing starts.

Reviews Sit Below Where Shoppers Look

The collection page ends with reviews, so anyone who does not scroll to the bottom never sees them. Social proof should appear earlier, where the buying decision begins.

Collection Filters Are Standard Theme Defaults

The sorting and filters on the ear studs page are the stock Shopify theme options. They do not reflect how people shop for jewellery, such as by style, colour, occasion or price.

Collection Cards Force Many Page Opens

Product cards show little beyond an image, a name and a price. Comparing four ear studs means opening four product pages, and comparing twenty means twenty, so shoppers give up.

Product Description Is Long And Hard To Scan

The necklace page runs a long block of description text. Key facts such as materials, dimensions and care are buried in it, so a shopper has to read paragraphs to find simple answers.

Returns And Checkout Costs Are Missing

Near Add to Cart the page mentions delivery but not returns, and does not say what the buyer will pay at checkout. Those two unanswered questions are common reasons to leave.

Bundles And Pairs Start Too Late

The necklace page works to raise order value, which is good, but pairs, sets and bundle savings do not appear on the homepage or collection pages where many shoppers first choose.

Recommendations

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

State what the store sells, who it is for and why it can be trusted in the first screen. Put a rating and the delivery promise directly under the headline so hesitation never starts.

Add Timing And Origin To The Delivery Promise

Next to free delivery, say when orders arrive and where and by whom the jewellery is made. Add a gift box mention if one is offered, so gift buyers can plan before they scroll.

Add A Product Finder To The Hero

Place a short guided finder as the main call to action. Ask who the piece is for and what style they like, then recommend products, the way a shop assistant would at the door.

Build Shop By Category Paths On The Homepage

Show clear tiles for earrings, necklaces, bracelets and ear studs straight after the hero. Each tile should lead to its collection so visitors can start exploring without opening the menu.

Organise The Navigation By Need

Group the menu by style, occasion, colour, budget and recipient so the choices are visible at once. Include under a set price points, which remove budget as a blocker for gift buyers.

Add Shop By Occasion And Colour Sections

Offer routes for everyday, evening, wedding and gifting, plus a shop by colour block for gold, green, pink and blue. Place them before the bestsellers so the range is shown first.

Move Reviews Higher On Every Page

Show the star rating near the top of the homepage and collection pages, and place review content above the fold on product pages. Pair written reviews with real customer photos.

Replace Standard Filters With Jewellery Filters

Add filters for type, style, price, colour, occasion and collection, and let visitors shop by need. Show how many pieces each collection holds so they know the size of the range.

Put Key Facts On Every Product Card

Add a badge, the rating, a one line summary and colour options to each card. Shoppers can then compare pieces at a glance without opening a page for each one.

Break The Description Into Scannable Cards

Replace the long text block with short cards for materials, dimensions and care, plus a brief note on what plating means. This educates the buyer and justifies the price at once.

Add Returns And Checkout Details Under Add To Cart

Place reassurances directly beneath the button covering delivery, exchanges and returns, secure checkout and what the buyer will pay. Answer the objection where it appears.

Add A Size Guide And Gift Message Option

Place a size guide close to the options and let buyers add a handwritten gift message before they add to cart. Both make gifting feel easier and remove small points of doubt.

Offer Pairs And Bundles From The Homepage

Add a buy the set section with a small saving on bundles, and a complete the look block on product pages. Jewellery suits pairing, so larger baskets are easy to earn.

Add Questions And FAQs To Collection Pages

Include a short set of questions about tarnish, plating and care on the homepage, and a fuller FAQ at the foot of each collection. This answers buyers early and helps search and AI assistants.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.

Homepage

The long page shown as two tall columns: a clear promise at the top, routes by category, occasion and gift budget, and sets, down to the footer.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Homepage, two tall columns

Three pages together

The homepage in the centre, the product page on the left with its buy column, and the earrings collection on the right with its header and filters.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Bag drawer

The slide-over bag open over the product page, with five pieces in it and a progress bar toward express delivery, so the whole screen reads at once.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

The finder quiz

Four taps, who it is for, the moment, the shape and the palette, then three picks ranked for her answers with a note on why and a matching piece to make a set.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Find Your Piece quiz, step by step

Product page

The full page in two columns: the buy box with proof beside the title, then the blocks that answer the questions a premium buyer has.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Product page, two tall columns

Product page first screen

The header and the whole buy box on one screen, with rating, key facts, set offer and delivery lines close to the button.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Product page first screen: header and buy box

Collection page first screen

The earrings page with a reason to buy in the header, style chips, ways to shop, filters and a first row of cards showing price, rating and colours.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Earrings collection first screen: header, filters, first row

Mega menus

Christmas, Earrings, Bracelets, Necklaces and Gifts, each panel open so the routes by style, occasion, colour, budget and recipient are visible from the top of the site.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Mega menu, every panel open

Search

A typed query with the matching piece shown right under the field, ready to add to the bag.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Search with a typed query

Mobile

Home, collection and product on three phone screens, built for one-handed use.

Helene Elisabeth Jewellery concept redesign: Three phone screens: home, collection, product
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • The jewellery is not the problem; the way the store presents it to a first time visitor is.
  • A homepage that lists products before it asks what the shopper wants behaves like a catalogue, not a shop.
  • Hesitation is a conversion killer, and it starts when the first screen does not say who the store is for.
  • Guided paths by category, occasion, budget and recipient give an undecided shopper somewhere to start.
  • If shoppers must open four pages to compare four products, the collection page is not doing its job.
  • The product page must handle objections, so delivery, returns and checkout costs belong next to Add to Cart.
  • Jewellery suits pairs and sets, so bundle offers should begin on the homepage, not only on the product page.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

Neither. The audit found that the products look good and that the store does not need more traffic first. The issue is that the visitors already arriving are not guided to the right piece or reassured enough to buy.

After the hero, the page lists products with only a name and a price. There are no guided routes by category, occasion, budget or recipient, so a visitor who is unsure what to buy has to work it out alone.

It shows that this is a jewellery store, but does not say who it is for or why others trust it. Free delivery is mentioned without timing, and nothing explains where or by whom the pieces are made.

The menu hides its contents until a visitor opens each item. There is no hint of how many collections or paths exist. The redesign groups the menu by style, occasion, colour, budget and recipient so the range is visible immediately.

On the ear studs page, comparing products means opening each product page. Cards that show a badge, rating, short summary and colour options let shoppers compare at a glance and reach the right piece sooner.

The necklace page has a bestseller label, reviews, a clear price and a delivery note. It also tries to raise order value, which our CRO strategist noted is rare among the stores reviewed.

Returns information and a clear indication of what the buyer will pay at checkout. Delivery is covered, but these two questions remain unanswered at the point where the shopper decides.

It starts earlier. A buy the set section with a bundle saving appears on the homepage, and product pages offer a complete the look pairing and a progress message toward free express delivery.

A short guided questionnaire in the hero. It asks who the piece is for and what style they like, then recommends products. It copies what a shop assistant would do when someone walks in and asks for help.

Three routes: keep the store as it is, implement the changes yourself, or have the studio do it. The studio options were a full rebuild at 3,500 paid in stages, a patch of the three reviewed pages, or the finished theme at 1,200.

The recording says a live Shopify store with better conversion rates is expected within four to five weeks. It also notes that results can take longer, and no outcome is promised.

The audit covers the homepage, the ear studs collection page and a necklace product page, followed by a redesign concept for each. The video runs 23 minutes and ends with options and pricing.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.