Skip to main content
Convertica Studio
CRO teardown Sterling Silver And Gold-Plated Jewellery

Thomasina Collection CRO Audit

A teardown of the Thomasina Collection jewellery store, covering the homepage, a rings collection page and a product page, with a clickable redesign concept built around guided buying.

12
Issues found
15
Fixes proposed
24
Minutes of tape
3.6
Overall / 10
24 min watch
01The teardown

Watch the full 24-minute recording.

Pressing play loads the video from YouTube — you can allow it for every teardown under cookie preferences.

02Executive summary

What we found.

Thomasina Collection sells sterling silver and gold-plated jewellery, from rings and huggies to pendants and clover pieces, and the range itself is a strength. Prices are approachable, with rings at £20 and £28, and the store already runs a 10% off plus free UK delivery offer. Ads are running and real visitors are arriving, so the traffic side is already moving.

The core problem is the presentation layer, not the products. The hero shows two women and no statement of what the shop does, who it is for or why it can be trusted. A visitor only knows this is jewellery because of the necklaces and bracelets further down. The navigation also hides its contents until each menu is opened, so no path is offered at the first step.

The same pattern repeats down the funnel. On the rings collection page the pieces differ only by colour and design, and the £20 and £28 prices come with no reason. Filtering and sorting are thin, so shoppers open page after page to compare. On the product page, questions about delivery, returns, materials and fit go unanswered, and no reviews appear anywhere on the site.

The direction is to replace the catalogue with a salesperson. State what the shop is in the hero, build navigation paths by type, style, metal and price, add a short guided finder, give each card a badge and rating, and bring reviews and bundles to the product page. Pause the extra ad spend until the site converts the traffic it has. A shop that guides is a shop that sells.

03The verdict

Problem, opportunity, impact

Core problem

The store presents jewellery like a catalogue. The hero does not say what the shop is, who it is for or why to trust it, and nothing guides a visitor from a grid of products to a confident purchase.

Main opportunity

Thomasina Collection could behave like a good salesperson in a physical shop: asking what the visitor needs, recommending pieces, answering delivery and returns questions, and offering pairs and bundles at the point of choice.

Estimated impact

More of the visitors already arriving from ads reach a piece they trust, add more than one item to the basket and complete checkout, so the same traffic produces more orders and a higher order value.

04How we audited

Scored across five dimensions.

3.6 Overall

Five dimensions, each scored out of ten.

The five passes
  1. 01
    Homepage & PDP review Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate, section by section.
  2. 02
    Mobile UX audit 70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  3. 03
    Trust & credibility check The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  4. 04
    Collection & discovery Filtering, merchandising and guidance from browse to buy.
  5. 05
    Prioritized CRO roadmap Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.
4 of 5 dimensions scoring four or below
Branding 5/10
UX 4/10
Trust 3/10
Product Page 3/10
Conversion 3/10
05What we'd fix

Every issue, paired with its fix.

12 issues found, 15 fixes proposed.

Problems identified

Hero Does Not Say What The Shop Is

The homepage hero shows two women and nothing else. It does not state what the business does, who it is for or why it can be trusted, so a visitor has to infer jewellery from the products below.

Navigation Hides Its Own Contents

A visitor has to open each menu item to learn what is inside. The first step of the buying journey offers no visible paths by type, style, metal or price.

Homepage Works Like A Catalogue

The homepage is a grid of images and names. It does not tell a visitor where to go or what to buy, and it ignores what the shopper is expecting to find.

No Reviews Anywhere On The Site

Reviews are missing from every page reviewed. For a jewellery brand people have not heard of, there is no previous buyer experience to lean on, and nobody wants to be the first to buy.

Collection Cards Cannot Be Compared

On the rings page the pieces differ only by colour and design. Nothing explains why one ring is £20 and another £28, so there is no reason to prefer one over the other.

Filters And Sorting Are Too Thin

Shoppers cannot narrow rings by metal, stone, motif, price or occasion. They open several product pages to compare and then leave out of frustration.

Product Page Leaves Questions Unanswered

Delivery, returns, arrival date, how the piece is made and how it looks when worn are not answered on the page where the Add to Cart decision happens.

Offer Banner Has No Clear Purpose

The 10% off plus free UK delivery message sits on the site with no role in the journey. It is not tied to a basket threshold or to buying more than one piece.

No Pairs Or Bundles To Lift Order Value

The product page makes no attempt to sell a ring with a bracelet, a charm or a second necklace. Jewellery pairs naturally and the page does not use that.

Product Price Is Never Justified

A £40 necklace sits next to cheaper lookalikes on marketplaces such as Etsy, eBay and Amazon, and the page gives no case for why this one is worth the price.

No Gifting Route For Gift Buyers

Visitors who came for themselves often buy for someone else, yet there is no gift entry by recipient, occasion or price, and no gift card or note option.

Ad Traffic Lands On A Weak Funnel

Ads are sending visitors to pages that do not yet convert them, so extra spend would only add more visitors to the same leaks.

Recommendations

Rewrite The Hero To Answer Three Questions

State what the shop sells, who it is for and why it can be trusted in the first screen, with delivery, returns and sterling silver and gold-plated details beside the headline.

Build A Guided Navigation Menu

Open each menu with paths by type, style, motif, metal and price, plus a reviews link, so a visitor looking only for earrings or necklaces reaches the right place in one hover.

Add A Two Button Hero Finder

Place two clear calls to action in the hero that start a short quiz and recommend pieces from the answers, the digital version of a shop assistant asking how they can help.

Replace The Product Grid With Shopping Paths

Organise the homepage by category, collection, occasion and recipient, followed by bestsellers, so every visitor has a route that matches how they want to shop.

Add Badges And Ratings To Every Product Card

Show a badge such as bestseller or customer favourite, a star rating and the key detail on each card, so pieces can be compared without opening the product page.

Add Richer Filters And Sorting To Collections

Let shoppers filter by type, metal, stone or finish, motif, price, occasion and gift, and sort the results, so they narrow a range of rings in seconds.

Add Quick Toggles Above Each Collection

Offer shortcuts such as huggies, pendants, clover, pearl and under £20 at the top of the page, so a shopper can jump to the group they want.

Collect And Display Reviews On Every Page

Start gathering reviews and show them on the homepage, collections and product pages, with customer photos where possible, so the first buyer is not left guessing.

Use Storewide Reviews On Unreviewed Products

Where a piece has no reviews of its own, show reviews from other products so visitors see that people have bought from the brand and been happy.

Answer Delivery And Returns Beside Add To Cart

Put delivery dates, returns, quality, secure checkout and materials directly under the button, so the common questions are settled before the visitor hesitates.

Add A Free Delivery Progress Bar

Show how far the basket is from free UK delivery beside Add to Cart, so a shopper who can spare a little more adds a second piece to qualify.

Offer Pairs And Complete The Look Bundles

Suggest a matching ring, bracelet, charm or smaller necklace on each product page, with a bundle discount, so one purchase becomes two or three.

Justify The Price On The Product Page

Add a section explaining materials, making and care, and why the piece is worth its price against marketplace alternatives, so cost feels earned.

Create A Gift Landing Page And Gift Options

Build a gifts route by recipient, occasion and price, and let buyers add a card and a personal note, so gift shoppers can finish quickly.

Fix The Funnel Before Scaling Ad Spend

Pause further ad growth until the redesigned pages convert current visitors, then scale, so more traffic means more orders and not more lost visitors.

06The redesign

The version we'd build.

A concept redesign created by Convertica Studio from this audit. It shows how the store could work, it is not the live store.

Homepage, two tall columns

**Homepage.** The full homepage shown as two tall columns: a clear statement of the brand, two ways in (find your piece or shop everything), categories sized to what the store sells and a route for gifts.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Homepage, two tall columns

Homepage centre, product left, collection right

**Three pages together.** The homepage in the centre, the product page on the left with its buy column and the shop-all collection page on the right with its filter rail and first cards.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Homepage centre, product left, collection right

Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

**The bag.** The product page dimmed behind the open bag drawer, shown whole from top to bottom, with a progress bar toward free delivery and a full set of lines.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Bag slide over open over the product page, whole screen

Find your piece quiz, step by step

**The quiz.** Find your piece, step by step: who it is for, the occasion, the piece, the style, gold or silver and the budget, ending on three matches with a reason for each and a piece to complete the look.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Find your piece quiz, step by step

Product page, two tall columns

**Product page.** The whole product page as two tall columns, from the buy box to the footer.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Product page, two tall columns

Product page first screen: header and buy box

**Buy box.** The first screen of the product page: header, photo gallery, length choice, Add to bag, express checkout, delivery date and free-delivery progress.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Product page first screen: header and buy box

Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

**Collection.** The first screen of the shop-all page: the banner, quick starting points, filters, ways to shop by need and the first row of cards with prices.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Collection page first screen: header, filters, first row

Mega menu, every panel open

**Mega menu.** Every panel opened one after another, from Earrings to Gifts, each with link columns, photo tiles and featured pieces.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Mega menu, every panel open

Three phone screens: home, collection, product

**Mobile.** Three phone screens side by side: home, collection and product, designed for thumbs first.

Thomasina Collection concept redesign: Three phone screens: home, collection, product
07Key takeaways

The teardown in 7 lines.

  • The jewellery is not the weak point; the way the site presents it is.
  • A hero should answer what the shop does, who it is for and whether it can be trusted within the first few seconds.
  • A collection page that only shows images and names behaves like a catalogue, not a salesperson.
  • Two rings at £20 and £28 need a visible reason for the difference, or the price looks arbitrary.
  • With no reviews on the site, every visitor is asked to be the first buyer.
  • Pairs, bundles and a free delivery threshold raise order value on a product that naturally goes with others.
  • More ad traffic only helps once the site converts the visitors it already receives.
08Questions

Questions this audit answers.

The store already runs ads and has visitors. The audit found that the pages do not help those visitors choose or feel confident, so extra traffic would reach the same leaks. Fixing conversion first makes every later visitor worth more.

A catalogue shows images, names and prices and leaves the choice to the visitor. The homepage and rings collection work this way, with no paths, comparisons or reasons to buy. A salesperson style site asks what the visitor needs and guides them.

A visitor decides within seconds whether a shop is for them. The current hero shows two women but does not say what the business does, who it serves or why it can be trusted, which creates hesitation before any product is seen.

Each menu has to be opened to see what it holds, so no buying path is visible at the first step. The concept opens menus by type, style, motif, metal, price and reviews, with a gifts route added.

No reviews appear anywhere on the site, and buyers want to see previous experiences before they commit. Where a piece has none yet, storewide reviews can show that people have bought from the brand and been satisfied.

Cards should carry a badge, a rating and the key detail of each piece, and the page needs filters for type, metal, stone, motif, price and occasion, plus sorting. That lets shoppers compare at a glance instead of opening each page.

It should answer delivery, returns, arrival date, materials, how the piece is made and how it looks worn, and explain why the price is fair. It should also show reviews and reassurance near the Add to Cart button.

Jewellery pairs easily, so product pages can suggest a ring, bracelet, charm or second necklace with a bundle discount. A bar showing the distance to free UK delivery also encourages a shopper to add another piece.

It is a short set of questions on the homepage that recommends products from the answers. It works like a shop assistant asking how they can help, and it supports discovery for visitors who do not know what to buy.

Visitors who do not find something for themselves often buy for a loved one. A gifts route by recipient, occasion and price, with a card and note option, gives those visitors a clear way to finish a purchase.

No. It is a clickable prototype made in Figma to show how the homepage, collection page and product page could remove friction. It reuses the existing offer, including 10% off and free UK delivery, and is a concept only.

The audit reviews the homepage, a rings collection page and a product page, then walks through a clickable redesign concept for each. The recording runs 24 minutes and ends with options for taking the work forward.

Free CRO audit

See what's quietly costing you sales.

Tell us about your store and we'll send a personalized 5-minute video showing exactly where you're losing buyers — and how to win them back.

Takes about 40 seconds. No call required.

What's included
  • 5-minute video teardown
    A personalized walkthrough of your store, recorded by Eva.
  • Homepage & PDP review
    Where attention leaks and buyers hesitate.
  • Mobile UX audit
    70% of your traffic — judged on its own terms.
  • Trust & credibility check
    The signals that make first-time buyers convert.
  • Prioritized CRO roadmap
    Ranked by impact vs. effort, ready to ship.